ARTICLE

We’ll Keep Swinging for Property Rights

BY WEN FA

November 20, 2026 12:54PM

Our clients are our heroes. They don’t just stand up for important principles–they tell powerful personal stories about why those principles matter.

Take Luis Clemente. His father, baseball legend Roberto Clemente, collected 3,000 hits and won several awards before dying tragically in a plane crash while delivering aid to earthquake victims in Nicaragua on New Year’s Eve in 1972.

For decades, Luis has made it his mission to preserve his father’s good name as a baseball player and a humanitarian. To that end, Luis and his brothers carefully steward the Roberto Clemente trademark to ensure that his name and image is used only for causes that carry on their father’s legacy. This includes causes like the Roberto Clemente Foundation, which provides everything from disaster relief to college scholarships, and the Clemente Museum in Pittsburgh, where I watched Luis regale visitors with stories about his father. To Luis and his brothers, the Clemente trademark is how they carry on their father’s legacy and honor his memory.

The Clementes were appalled when they watched Puerto Rico make $15 million off their father’s name, against their express wishes, without paying the family a dime.

To mark the 50th anniversary of Roberto Clemente’s 3,000th hit, Puerto Rico stuck his image on commemorative license plates and registration tags in 2022 and forced drivers to pay extra for them. Financially strapped Puerto Ricans were furious about the new fees and blamed the Clementes, even though the family had opposed them from the beginning. So the Clementes took Puerto Rico to court to preserve their father’s good name and hold the government accountable for infringing on their rights.

The Constitution requires the government to pay for what it takes. If Puerto Rico had seized a family farm to build a ballpark, no one would doubt that it owed the family a check. But a federal appeals court rejected our claim, holding that the Clementes were not entitled to the same protections as other property owners simply because it was their intangible property at stake. In the court’s view, the simple pay-for-what-you-take rule covers only things you can touch, like land, cars, or crops.

That is wrong. The Constitution protects “private property” without distinguishing between different kinds. Trademarks share the essential features of every other kind of property—most importantly, the right to keep others from using them. You don’t really own your house or your car if others can use it at their leisure. The same is true of trademarks.

This isn’t a new idea. From the English common law to recent decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court, judges have long recognized that trademarks prevent others from piggybacking off the goodwill that a person has built in his name. Roberto Clemente and his family have built the Clemente legacy over decades of hard work on and off the field. Puerto Rico’s choice to profit off the Clemente name is no less a taking of their property than if Puerto Rico sold baseball memorabilia belonging to the Clemente family and pocketed the money for itself.

One doesn’t have to look too closely to see how this matters in Tennessee. Nashville’s songwriters, Knoxville’s college athletes, and iconic Tennessee brands like Jack Daniel’s all depend on intellectual property. If the government can use their names, songs, and logos without paying, none of that property is safe. Whether it’s a farmer’s crops in rural Tennessee or a songwriter’s work in the heart of Music City, the government should pay for what it takes.

On November 9, the Supreme Court declined to hear their case. That’s disappointing, but the game isn’t over. The Clemente family’s federal trademark claims against Puerto Rico officials are headed back to the district court, and the family will keep fighting all the way back to the Supreme Court if necessary. Roberto Clemente never let one bad call define him, and neither will we. We will keep swinging for the fences for property rights.